Read our story

A long history of great food.

Jack and Gary Tiply are no strangers to Mario's. Having owned the establishment for nearly 30 years, they've reestablished ownership of the beloved Setauket mainstay in 2021.

The brothers are joined by lifelong best friend Billie Phillips in a classic reboot of one of the oldest and most notable Italian restaurants on the North Shore. The combination of three successful restaurateurs promises a Mario's that will be better than ever.

Our Food

Fresh Pasta

From Linguini to Lasagna

Meat & Fish

Both Traditional & Unique

Homemade Pizza

Crafted or Build Your Own

Special Happenings

Onsite Dining

Our INDOOR DINING SAFETY MEASURES: MERV-13 Rated HEPA Air Filtration in place. Economizer set to bring in fresh, outdoor air. Each dining room has independent systems.